|
| |
| OSHA |
| Steingass Mechanical’s OSHA
Policy – Tell them Nothing |
| When a construction company like
Steingass Mechanical Contracting, Inc. has received over 30 OSHA violations,
they have several options. Some companies bring OSHA in at the start of the
job, or the company will bring in experienced safety consultants to do
pre-job inspections to make sure the job gets off to a safe start. Other
companies hire ex-OSHA inspectors and give them free rein to enforce safety
rules at their job site. Then there is the Steingass Mechanical's approach
as described in a recent OSHA inspection report: "The foreman was very
uncooperative and gave the CSHO [the OSHA inspector] a paper that stated the
foreman is not to give CSHO any information, not to permit CSHO to talk to
employees and not to permit an inspection."
Not surprisingly, when OSHA finally gained access to that job site, even
though Steingass Mechanical had advance notice that OSHA was coming, OSHA
found a serious violation of scaffolding rules. An employee was working on a
mobile scaffold with unlocked casters and there were additional violations
"concerning the lack of training for employees working on scaffolding." OSHA
concluded that the worker was in danger of severe contusions and abrasions,
and issued a serious violation and proposed a $750 fine against Steingass
Mechanical.
Steingass Mechanical’s "tell them nothing policy" was not the result of a
foreman having a bad day, but it was official Steingass Mechanical company
policy. As OSHA discovered, "the foreman ... referred CSHO to an instruction
sheet from the company which stated the foreman was not to assist [sic] or
participate in the inspection [sic]."
Steingass Mechanical’s policy of attempting to stonewall OSHA did not
save the company at this job site at 997 West Aurora Road in Sagamore, Ohio.
OSHA issued a serious citation and proposed a fine against Steingass
Mechanical. (Inspection # 302506449)
Another Serious OSHA Violation for Steingass Mechanical
Less than one year later, OSHA inspected another Steingass Mechanical job
site. This site was located at the new high school at 9530 Bauer Avenue in
Windham, Ohio. On May 15, 2000 OSHA issued yet another serious violation
notice against Steingass Mechanical and proposed a $1,400 fine. This time
OSHA found that Steingass Mechanical did not use ground fault circuit
interrupters or an assured equipment grounding conductor program.
Specifically, an "electrical cord furnishing power for a RIGID 300 pipe
threader did not have a permanent and continuous" electrical grounding
device. OSHA stated this violation left the workers in danger of suffering
burns and an impact injury. Steingass Mechanical’s work was stopped
immediately and the employees left the site. (Inspection #118122589)
Steingass Mechanical’s OSHA Proposed Violations Total 31, Fines exceed
$12,000
In previous years, Steingass Mechanical had received a total of 28 OSHA
violations. The top three recent violations push Steingass Mechanical's
total of OSHA violations to 31 and the amount of proposed fines to over
$12,000. |
| OSHA Violations |
| Job
Location |
Inspection
# |
Fine
|
Violation |
| Windham, OH |
118122589 |
$ 1,400
|
2 Serious |
| Sagamore Hills,
OH |
302506449 |
$ 750
|
1 Serious |
| Westfield Center,
OH |
103543419 |
$ 675
|
1 Serious |
| Ravenna, OH |
300102449 |
$ -
|
1 Other |
| Strongsville, OH |
103012316 |
$ 375 |
1 Serious |
| Aurora, OH |
121936256 |
$ 500
|
1 Repeat |
| Bedford Heights,
OH |
109778944 |
$ 675 |
1 Serious, 2
Other |
| Brook Park, OH |
103510152 |
$ 225
|
1 Serious |
| Cleveland, OH
|
108835026 |
$ 5,700
|
4 Serious |
| Wooster, OH |
108836115 |
$ 375 |
1 Serious |
| Cleveland, OH |
108837477 |
$ - |
1 Other |
| Beachwood, OH |
108841867 |
$ 1,140
|
3 Serious, 1
Other |
| Wadsworth, OH |
103219226 |
$ 200
|
1 Serious, 1
Other |
| Mayfield Heights,
OH |
103017901 |
$ 580
|
2 Repeat |
| Brunswick, OH
|
101282408 |
$ 120 |
1 Serious, 1
Other |
| Akron, OH |
101289502 |
$ -
|
3 Other |
|
$12,715 in OSHA fines against Steingass Mechanical
Contracting
A 2:1 ratio of Serious & Repeated Violations to Other
(Minor) Violations (20 Serious & Repeated to 10 Other)
The violations listed above reflect initial citations and fines. The
amounts may have been reduced or bargained down at later dates. |

|