ROOFER IMPALED AFTER FALL FROM
SCAFFOLD: OLSON V. HAWKINS, OTHERSClay Olson was a roofer who was
supposed to install roofing at the University of Nebraska at Omaha Fine Arts
Building. Hawkins was the general contractor on this job. While attempting
to ascend to the roof, Olson fell from the scaffolding, and after he fell 15
feet, his pelvis was impaled on a scaffold pole. He suffered severe,
disabling injury, and his medical bills alone were almost $70,000. According
to his court complaint, Hawkins failed to properly and adequately supervise
the construction of the scaffold.
WORKER INJURED AT HAWKINS’ BENSON HIGH SCHOOL JOB: HARDESTY V. HAWKINS
Hawkins was the general contractor on a roofing job at Benson High School
in Omaha, Nebraska. Hawkins attempted to bridge two sections of the roof
with a steel ramp. But Elmer Hardesty slipped on the ramp and suffered
painful back injuries. Hardesty incurred medical expenses of almost $18,000.
His complaint charged that Hawkins:
". . . failed to properly supervise the repairing of the roof, failed
to provide standard railing for crossing over walkways, failed to provide
a ramp that was properly designed and constructed by qualified persons,
failed to leave spaces in the ramps so that any mud, oil etc. would pass
through the openings and provide better traction for workers, and failed
to provide a safe place to work."
HAWKINS LEAVES HOLE IN ROOF, WORKER FALLS: HARRISON, OTHERS, V. HAWKINS
Hawkins was the general contractor on the construction of the water plant
in Ashland, Nebraska. During that work, Hawkins cut a hole in the roof of
the plant. Charles Harrison, a 50-year-old roofer, fell through the hole,
and suffered permanent injuries. His medical bills were almost $7,000. His
court complaint charged that Hawkins:
" . . . failed to cover or otherwise mark the hole, after making it in
the roof, failed to warn Harrison about the hole, and failed to inspect
the premises to insure that the hole remained covered."
DRUNKEN HAWKINS SUPERVISOR CAUSED INJURY TO WORKERS FACE, CHARGES COURT
COMPLAINT: McCLARNON V. HAWKINS
Russell McClarnon and a Hawkins supervisor were carrying a 150 pound
piece of plywood at a job site. But the supervisor was drunk, and dropped
his end of the plywood. The plywood then struck McClarnon in the nose and
face. He suffered severe and permanent injuries, and his medical bills
HAWKINS’ NEGLIGENCE INJURES FIVE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC
In the following case a Hawkins customer, the City of Omaha was sued on a
case where a member of the public was injured while walking near the Hawkins
job site. In other cases, Hawkins’ negligence is blamed for traffic
accidents near a Hawkins job and on Omaha’s streets.
NISLY V. HAWKINS
|
When Darlene Nisly was walking by the site, she
tripped over a high spot in the paving and fell. She tore the rotator
cup in her shoulder... |
Hawkins was working on a construction job for the City of Omaha Police
Plaza. When Darlene Nisly was walking by the site, she tripped over a high
spot in the paving and fell. She tore the rotator cup in her shoulder and
suffered other injuries. She sued Hawkins, charging that Hawkins negligently
had failed to warn of the danger posed by the irregular paving, and failed
to provide a safe path through the site. Just as importantly, she sued the
City of Omaha, who was Hawkins’ construction customer, for the same
failures.
PETERSON V. HAWKINS, GEARHART V. HAWKINS
In these two cases, Hawkins was performing work on Interstate 480, and
had piled huge mounds of topsoil to the side of the Interstate. But it
rained that summer, and large amounts of water and earth spilled onto the
highway. In August, Jeffery Gearhart was driving his Suzuki motorcycle along
I-480, when he hit this accumulation of water and mud. His cycle slid out of
control, and he suffered injuries. But Hawkins did not correct this problem.
So, the next month, Gordon Peterson came driving along I-480, this time on
an older model Suzuki. He also skidded through the water and mud, and also
crashed, suffering severe back injuries.
Here are two court cases involving traffic accidents. While these cases
may seem unimportant at first glance, the injured parties in similar cases
have sued the customer of the construction company that was involved in the
accident.
SMART V. HAWKINS
Brigitte Smart was driving her Toyota Camry near downtown Omaha, when a
Hawkins truck forced her off of the road, into a parked car. Smart suffered
back injuries.
WESLEY V. HAWKINS
Rhonda Wesley was driving through south Omaha, when a Hawkins truck rear
ended her car. Her medical expenses for her permanent and painful back
injuries, totaled over $35,500.
alone exceeded $12,000. His suit charged that Hawkins was liable for the
gross and negligent actions of their supervisor.
MAURER V. HAWKINS, OTHERS
Hawkins won the contract to remove the 24th Street
train viaduct in south Omaha. But when Hawkins tried to lift up the viaduct
with three cranes, the structure fell to pieces, scattering heavy iron and
concrete chunks like an explosion. A piece of iron struck Alvin Mauer, a
Hawkins supervisor. He suffered severe and disfiguring injuries, and his
right arm is virtually useless. The suit charged the defendants in this
case, which included Hawkins, with failing to properly review the
engineering information necessary to perform a safe removal of the viaduct.
Union Pacific, the city of Omaha, and the State of Nebraska were also sued.
This case illustrates an important reason why construction customers must be
concerned about litigation. If the contractor makes a mistake and workers or
members of the public are injured, the construction customer is still
liable. In this case, Union Pacific eventually filed a cross-complaint
against Hawkins in November, 1999. The complaint charged the Hawkins was
obligated to indemnify Union Pacific against any claims and damages
HAWKINS’ JOBS GO BAD IN OMAHA:
• FATHER FLANAGAN SUES HAWKINS FOR DAMAGES AT BOYS TOWN
• HAWKINS CAUSES WALL CAVE-IN AT CREIGHTON UNIVERSITY
• HAWKINS CEMENT POUR CLOGS UP UNDERGROUND SEWERS IN DOWNTOWN OMAHA
FATHER FLANAGAN V. HAWKINS
Boys Town, a pastoral campus west of Omaha, has been taking care of
wayward boys for most of this century. It was memorialized in a 1930’s movie
starring Spencer Tracy, and by its logo: one boy carrying a younger lad over
his shoulder, exclaiming, "He ain’t heavy father, he’s my brother." But this
court case indicates that Hawkins Construction lacked respect for the Boys
Town mission.
The problems began when Hawkins started its highway job near Boys Town,
on Dodge Street. When the March rains came, "substantial and extraordinary
amounts of silt" and mud flowed from the exposed grounds of the construction
site, onto the Boys Town campus, and into Father Flanagan’s Lake. These
sediment deposits damaged the lake and surrounding property. Father
Flanagan’s representatives immediately notified Hawkins of the problems on
several occasions. But Hawkins did not take the necessary preventative
measures, including erecting and maintaining silt fences, siltation basins,
and by seeding promptly the exposed dirt slopes at the construction site.
Father Flanagan sued Hawkins for over $102,000, for the costs of
inspecting and then dredging the silt from the lake. This is one of four
court cases that charge Hawkins with causing property damages by failing to
control run-off and erosion at their construction sites. Hawkins had a
run-in with another of Omaha’s Catholic icons in the next case, this one
involving Creighton University.
HAWKINS HAS MORE PROBLEMS WITH STORM WATER RUN-OFF
K-T company V. HAWKINS, CREIGHTON UNIVERSITY
Both Hawkins, and their customer, Creighton University, were sued in this
case. Creighton had hired Hawkins to work on a retaining wall that bordered
the Creighton Campus. But in the course of removing the old wall, Hawkins so
weakened the remaining walls, that a rainstorm caused a remaining wall to
collapse against an apartment house, causing over $90,000 in damages. The
suit charged that Hawkins was negligent for the following reason:
"Hawkins negligently failed to secure Creighton University’s remaining
retaining wall, failed to place area drains at Creighton’s retaining wall,
to relieve hydrostatic pressure, and diminished the strength of the
remaining retaining wall."
A HAWKINS CEMENT POUR FLOWED INTO OMAHA’S DOWNTOWN SEWER SYSTEM
CITY OF OMAHA V. HAWKINS, WOODMEN OF THE WORLD
The Woodmen of the World Insurance Society hired Hawkins to build a new
parking lot in downtown Omaha. But when Hawkins commenced their cement pour
for the foundation, Hawkins failed to notice that their wet cement was
flowing into an uncapped sewer lateral. The concrete flowed into an adjacent
sewer line, and set, totally blocking that sewer with hardened concrete.
The City began receiving complaints about blocked sewers, and had to
excavate the area, discover the concrete deposits and repair the area.
The City sued not only Hawkins, but Hawkins customers, the Woodmen
Society. The City charged:
"Hawkins failed to properly supervise the capping of sewer line, failed
to properly supervise the construction of the parking garage, and poured
concrete in such large quantities that they should have been aware that
the sewer line was not capped."
The Contractor’s Critic wondered this, too. Didn’t Hawkins notice that it
was pouring far too much concrete for the size of the job? Did the Woodmen
have to pay Hawkins for the scores of square yards of concrete that got
poured into the city sewers?
disputes with contractors
Hawkins has had several disputes with its subcontractors and suppliers.
These disputes can blow up and harm the construction customers, especially
if an angry supplier or subcontractor files a lien against the construction
customer’s property.
HAWKINS V. INTERSTATE detroit diesel, WALDINGER V. HAWKINS
These two court cases revolve around Hawkins’ work on the Skyline
Reservoir, for the Metropolitan Utilities District, west of Omaha. Hawkins
subcontracted with Waldinger to install several pumps. But Hawkins refused
to pay Waldinger for the total cost of the pumps. So Waldinger had to sue
Hawkins.
Then Hawkins sued the pump supplier, Interstate, charging that the pumps
cost more than was fair.
SADLER LINE construction V. HAWKINS
Hawkins subcontracted traffic light work to Sadler Line, on a highway
job. But Hawkins refused to pay Sadler the $124,490 that was due, so Sadler
had to sue.
HAWKINS V. AMOCO oil company
Most of us, including the Hawkins workers, will never get to drive a
Ferrari. From 1984 to 1996, the Testarossa model was not only the top of the
Ferrari line, but for most of that time it was the fastest regular
production sports car in the world. It was the definition of "supercar" in
its era, the benchmark against which all sports cars are measured.
It is fast and sleek and temperamental, and a pure joy to handle on the
open road. But you have to be careful. Fred Hawkins, Jr., the President of
Hawkins, pumped diesel into his Ferrari Testarossa. That ruined the engine
and drive train, causing over $25,000 in damages. He sued Amoco, the service
station where he pumped the diesel, for the damages.